The Night Desk · Season 1 · Case 14 · Sunday cold case ·

The Salt Ledger

Ten years ago the salt works lost its wages and forty men lost their jobs. Tonight the last ledger came back.

The case file

Sunday cold case. Ten years ago this month, the night before payday, the Merrow Salt Works lost its wages: $1,200 in an iron safe in the counting house. The safe was opened with its own key, and the lock was not scratched. The works closed by Christmas and forty men were out of work.

This week Cass Rendle bought the works' last ledger at a Saltholm auction and left it on the desk with a note: page 40. In the back the clerk had copied out the old statements. Five people were on the works that night, one each in the counting house, the boiling house, the salt store, the canteen and down at the wharf. Each had one thing in hand: the safe key, a salt sack, a handcart, a coal shovel or a pair of oars. The one who opened the safe lied then and lies now.

Who was there

  • Josiah Trudgeon, manager of the salt works. Gray at the temples now, with a good coat and a handshake that lasts too long.
  • Captain Morwenna Hext, skipper of the salt barge Gannet. Weathered, unhurried, a pipe she never lights clamped in her teeth.
  • Mrs. Effie Carne, cook at the works canteen. Round, rosy and still angry, ten years on.
  • Walter Nance, pan foreman. Burn scars on both forearms and the patience of a man who boiled brine for a living.
  • Ivy Treen, clerk at the works, then nineteen. Neat handwriting, a librarian now, and she remembers everything.

The places: the counting house, the boiling house, the salt store, the canteen and the wharf.

The means: the safe key, a salt sack, a handcart, a coal shovel and a pair of oars.

Case 14 · Sunday, November 8

The questioning room

This case's night is Sunday, November 8, from midnight your time. The questioning room plays here with JavaScript on; the case file above reads without it.

The inspector's note: A liar sits where the collisions cross

With five witnesses there may be more than one pair of claims that cannot both be true. Each pair tells you the liar is one of two people. Write down every pair, then look for the name that appears in all of them. If only one name sits inside every collision, you have found the liar without testing anyone, and the honest witnesses do the rest.

How to solve a Night Desk case, with a worked example.

The solution

The night desk's write-up appears here once you solve the case, or from Monday, November 9, the night after it opens.